To begin, I purchased tea lights from the dollar store. There were 8 in a package for a dollar. I got the cream card stock paper from Michaels and I already had yarn around the house.
I borrowed a lamp from my mom's friend that I used to make a template. She got the lamp from Deseret Book for $2.99. I traced the lamp onto the card stock (and uploaded a copy here for you to use if you would like).
Here is a picture of the complete template.
I cut the lamps out and glued on the tea light. I punched a hole in the end and used yarn to tie on a scripture that I typed up. The reference I used was Matthew 25:13. After the lesson, which turned out well, we passed out the handouts.